Diagnosis · Autism guide

Autism diagnosis and self-identification: who gets to belong?

By Helen Edgar and David Gray-Hammond · From the Re-Storying Autism workbook, Module 2

At a glanceDiagnosis is not neutralIt can help with support, language and community, but it is not a prerequisite for identity.
  • Racial bias
  • Gender bias
  • Class bias
  • Linguistic expectations
  • Limits of observation-based assessment
  • Stereotypes from early research

Diagnostic systems are not neutral. They reflect the biases, values, and cultural assumptions of the societies in which they are created. Autism diagnosis is shaped by:

  • Racial bias
  • Gender bias
  • Class bias
  • Linguistic expectations
  • Limitations of observation-based assessment
  • Stereotypes rooted in early work dominated by white male samples and the idea that autism is a childhood disorder
  • The pathologising agenda of psychiatry

Diagnosis can be helpful for accessing support, language, and community. But diagnosis is not a prerequisite for identity, nor is it a moral endorsement from medical professionals.

Keep going in the course

This is a short extract. The full lesson in Module 2: Identity, Language and Disability Models includes the video teaching, the rest of the workbook text, reflective questions for Autistic people, carers and practitioners, and progress tracking.

Explore the course

More guides

Words to know

From the Neuro-Affirming Glossary of Key Words and Terms (2026 Edition) by Helen Edgar, Autistic Realms.

Self-Identification Starting point
Recognising yourself as neurodivergent, for example Autistic or ADHD, without a formal diagnosis. Being able to get a diagnosis is a privilege that many people do not have, because of waiting lists, cost or bias. Diagnosis is a gateway to some support, not a test of who you are. Self-identification is valid.
Neuronormativity Going deeper
In Sonny Jane Wise’s (2023) words, “a set of norms, standards, expectations and ideals that centre a particular way of functioning as the right way to function”. Hardly anyone fits it fully, and Wise argues that it disadvantages everyone, including neurotypical people.
Social Model of Disability Starting point
People are disabled by environments, attitudes and systems built without them in mind, not by their differences alone. Support means changing environments and expectations, not people (Oliver, 1983).
Identity First Language Starting point
This means putting a person’s identity first. For example, using identity first language, you would use the term ‘Autistic person’ (not ‘person with autism’, which is person first language). Identity first language is often considered preferable in the Autistic community (Kenny et al., 2016; Keating et al., 2023), but it is always good to ask someone how they prefer to identify and respect their choice.

Read all 222 words free on Helen’s glossary page at autisticrealms.com. Thank you to Helen for writing them.

Subscribe to The Wider Existence, our free newsletter